Taking Risks

As adults, many of us (and by many of us I mean me) are reluctant to have others read what they've written. We're afraid that they'll judge our ideas, the way we write, or even our punctuation. We don't see other's suggestions to our work as an opportunity for improvement as much as we see it as a personal attack on who we are as writers. This makes sense of course, given that most of our lives anything we'd ever written for a class has come back to us covered in red pen. I'm not saying that those comments don't have their place, but there should be another avenue for teachers than to mark up every piece of writing presented by their students.

Routman's ideas about writing conferences seem like a valid way to combat the stigma associated with constructive criticism in writing. Having content and editing conferences with students before they publish eliminates much of the frustration in getting back a marked up piece of published work. Her approach to writing as a collaborative effort allows students to work together to come up with ideas as well as creates an atmosphere where students aren't afraid to share their writing with their classmates. Additionally, she allows students to create their own goals so that the conference process is more student centered than curriculum centered.